Law and regulation
Working out what applies to you
Law, mandates, standards and good practice; must, should and could; and why devolution matters.
Five kinds of rule
Not everything you're told to "comply with" has the same force. The applicability matrix labels every entry with one of these types:
| Type | What it is | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Legislation | Acts and regulations. A legal duty, enforced by regulators or the courts. | UK GDPR, FOI Act |
| Mandated policy | Rules set by government, the NHS or a regulator for bodies in scope, enforced through assurance, contracts or spend controls. | DSPT, DCB0160, Technology Code of Practice |
| Standard | Published standards, usually certifiable. Voluntary unless a contract or mandate requires them. | ISO/IEC 20000-1, Cyber Essentials |
| Framework | Good practice you adopt and adapt. | ITIL 4, the CAF |
| Guidance | Official guidance, strategies and routes to market. | Orange Book, G-Cloud |
Must, should, could
The matrix also says how strongly each entry applies to each sector:
- Must: required by law, or by a mandate that applies to you. Not doing it is a breach.
- Should: expected. Regulators, assurers or commissioners will look for it, or contracts normally require it.
- Could: good practice worth adopting, not required.
The same instrument can be a must for one sector and a could for another. For example, DCB0160 is a must for NHS organisations in England but good practice for HSC in Northern Ireland.
Why devolution matters
Health, social care, many public records duties, procurement for devolved bodies and some information rights are devolved. So the four nations often have different rules for the same thing:
| Topic | England | Wales | Scotland | Northern Ireland |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Freedom of information | FOI Act 2000 | FOI Act 2000 | FOI (Scotland) Act 2002 | FOI Act 2000 |
| Health data security assurance | DSPT | NHS Wales arrangements | NHS Scotland arrangements | HSC arrangements |
| Clinical safety of health IT | DCB0129 / DCB0160 (mandatory) | Good practice | Good practice | Good practice |
| Equality duty | Equality Act 2010 | Equality Act 2010 | Equality Act 2010 | Section 75, NI Act 1998 |
| Language | – | Welsh language standards | – | – |
Data protection, NIS and the Computer Misuse Act apply UK-wide, though the regulator or competent authority can differ.
If you provide a service across more than one nation (a national supplier, a UK-wide body, or a cross-border service), check each nation separately. "The NHS" isn't one organisation with one rulebook.
A quick method
- Who are you? Choose your sector in the matrix.
- Where do you operate? Filter by nation; UK-wide items always show.
- What does the contract say? Contracts often turn should and could into must.
- Check the source. Every entry links to its primary source. This site summarises; the source decides.